After 5+ years together Sarah Silverman and Jimmy Kimmel are calling it quits.

“Jimmy and Sarah are no longer dating and will have no further comment,” said the couple’s spokespersons collectively.

Sarah once said of her boyfriend jokingly, “I’m Jewish, but I wear this Saint Christopher medal sometimes; my boyfriend is Catholic, but you know… it was cute the way he gave it to me. He said if it doesn’t burn a hole through my skin it will protect me.”